My client has capacity but are they really able to engage?

Contact the Legal Lexi today

transparency informed consent legal costs

One of the most common misconceptions in legal practice is that a client who has mental capacity needs no additional support. In reality, capacity and vulnerability are not the same thing.

The Mental Capacity Act 2005 provides a clear legal framework for determining whether an individual can make a particular decision. If a person can understand, retain, use and weigh information and communicate their decision, they have capacity.

But that assessment tells us very little about how easily that person can navigate the legal process.

A client may have capacity while simultaneously dealing with grief, trauma, domestic abuse, illness, financial pressure, learning difficulties or overwhelming anxiety. They may understand the information presented to them but struggle to process lengthy documents, ask questions or appreciate the practical consequences of their decisions.

This distinction matters because legal services are rarely purchased in ideal circumstances. Clients often seek legal advice during periods of significant stress and uncertainty. A person going through a divorce, administering the estate of a loved one or pursuing a personal injury claim may be perfectly capable of making decisions, yet still be vulnerable in ways that affect their ability to engage meaningfully with their lawyer.

For solicitors, identifying these vulnerabilities is critical. It enables them to adapt their communication, provide information in a more accessible way and take additional steps to ensure that clients genuinely understand the advice being given. This may involve simplifying language, breaking information into manageable stages, checking understanding more frequently or providing extra opportunities for discussion.

Importantly, recognising vulnerability is also central to informed consent. A signed document may evidence agreement, but it does not necessarily demonstrate understanding.

The question for lawyers should therefore never be limited to, “Does my client have capacity?” It should also be, “What barriers might prevent this client from fully participating in the legal process, and what can I do to help?”

By moving beyond a simple capacity assessment and embracing a more holistic understanding of vulnerability, lawyers can improve client outcomes, reduce complaints and build stronger, more trusting professional relationships. Capacity may open the door to legal decision-making, but recognising vulnerability is often the key to ensuring that justice is truly accessible.

Using our platform, The Legal Lexi®, helps the lawyer and client explore their, often hidden, vulnerabilities in a non-confrontational forum.

Book you free demonstration today to learn how The Legal Lexi® can assist you. Email info@thelegallexi.co.uk

Still unsure?

Schedule a live demo via Teams and see in less than 30 minutes how The Legal Lexi can easily fit into your firm’s workflows to give you confidence that you have your clients’ informed consent and protect your entitlement to costs.

Click to book a demo